Pirates Fire Shelton — Could Yankees’ Boone Be Next?
The Pittsburgh Pirates made headlines on Thursday by firing manager Derek Shelton after five seasons. Shelton’s tenure ended with a disappointing record of 307 wins and 441 losses, and not a single postseason appearance. While the decision wasn’t entirely shocking given the Pirates’ consistent struggles, it sparked speculation about which MLB manager might be next on the chopping block.
Surprisingly, some eyes are now turning toward New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone. On paper, Boone’s job appears secure — he’s guided the Yankees to 625 wins and just 446 losses across eight seasons. The team has only missed the postseason once under his leadership, in 2023, and they reached the World Series for the first time in his tenure just last year. As of Sunday, the Yankees sit atop the AL East with a 22-17 record, two games ahead of their bitter rivals, the Boston Red Sox.
So why is Boone suddenly under scrutiny?
Despite the recent success, frustration is brewing among Yankees fans and commentators who believe Boone’s inability to bring a championship to the Bronx is unacceptable — especially given the franchise’s proud legacy of 27 World Series titles. Some critics argue that Boone’s in-game decisions, bullpen management, and lack of accountability are glaring flaws. Fansided’s Mark Powell didn’t hold back last weekend, declaring Boone “on the hot seat” and accusing him of acting like a rookie manager despite years of experience.
Bleacher Report also added fuel to the fire, naming Boone among six MLB managers currently on shaky ground. While others on the list — like Atlanta’s Brian Snitker — have already hoisted a World Series trophy, Boone’s resume still lacks that elusive championship ring, making his tenure all the more frustrating for Yankees loyalists.
Criticism has escalated to full-on outrage in some corners. Robert Casey of Bleeding Yankee Blue launched a blistering attack on Boone, calling him “a fraud” and “the most unqualified manager in Yankees history.” He accused Boone of spinning narratives, making poor lineup decisions, and deflecting blame onto young players. Casey’s message to the front office was blunt: wake up and make a change, or risk dragging the team further into mediocrity.
As the season unfolds, Boone’s future with the Yankees may hinge not only on wins — but on whether he can finally deliver the ultimate prize in a city that accepts nothing less than championships.
Leave a Reply