At this point in the season, it’s time for Aaron Boone and the Yankees to rethink their strategy for the closer role. Devin Williams’ struggles have complicated the situation, but that doesn’t mean he should be removed from the role entirely. Instead, the Yankees should consider a more flexible, strategic approach. Williams was brought in this offseason to stabilize the closer position after Clay Holmes had a rough 2024, but things haven’t gone smoothly.
Just over a month into the season, Williams has pitched in 15 games with 12 2/3 innings under his belt, posting a 1–2 record and a 9.24 ERA—down slightly from a peak over 11.00. He’s recorded four saves, blown one, and holds an 80% save rate. Opponents are batting .265 against him, and while he’s struck out 16 batters, his 11 walks in limited innings are a major concern. A closer can’t afford to give away free bases, and Williams’ command issues are proving costly.
The Yankees shouldn’t give up on him—but they should manage his appearances more carefully. Rather than using him as a one-size-fits-all closer, Boone should consider a situational approach based on matchups, game context, and Williams’ recent performance. Other relievers are capable of finishing games, and using them selectively could take some pressure off Williams while helping him rebuild confidence.
The key is reading the moment: Is the game on the line? Is there a real threat of the opponent tying or walking it off? These questions should guide when and how Williams is used going forward.
Leave a Reply