Quiet but Crucial: Giants’ Right Guard Battle Could Shape the Offense in 2025
Every offseason brings its share of position battles, but the fight for the New York Giants’ right guard spot might be one of the most underrated storylines — and one of the most important.
It’s not a glamorous competition, but it could directly impact the team’s ability to protect its new-look quarterback room and establish any kind of offensive rhythm.
The Veteran Advantage — For Now
Greg Van Roten isn’t a superstar, but he’s dependable. In 2024, he logged 1,121 snaps, gave up 35 pressures and seven sacks — solid if unspectacular numbers. He brings consistency and durability, two things the Giants’ battered offensive line desperately needs after last season’s struggles.
With a modest salary and reliable play, Van Roten gives the Giants something they can work with — stability. And right now, that matters more than flash.
The X-Factor: Evan Neal’s Make-or-Break Transition
Evan Neal, once considered a foundational piece at tackle, has had a rough start to his NFL career. Injuries and inconsistent play have led to a major shift: the Giants are moving him inside to guard in hopes of salvaging his potential.
At 6’7” and 350 pounds, Neal certainly has the size to compete on the interior. But switching from tackle to guard is a major adjustment — it means quicker decisions, new angles, and very different technique.
Neal played just 459 snaps last season and allowed 17 pressures. His struggles on the edge were well-documented, and while the move to guard could help, it won’t be an instant fix.
A Last Chance to Unlock First-Round Value
Neal is still young — not even 25 — and the Giants aren’t giving up on him. But this transition feels like a final shot to get value out of a high draft pick who hasn’t delivered yet.
If Neal adapts quickly and stays healthy — two big question marks — he could surpass Van Roten and become a long-term answer at the position. That’s the ideal outcome.
More realistically, though, he’ll need time to develop. Expect him to begin the season as a backup, with the hope that he earns his way into the lineup later on.
A Low-Profile Battle with High Stakes
This isn’t the kind of position battle that makes headlines, but the stakes are real. Every missed assignment, every pressure allowed could make or break the offense.
If Van Roten holds the job and performs solidly, the Giants can shift focus to bigger concerns. But if Neal surprises everyone and finally turns the corner, this quiet competition could end up being one of the most impactful stories of the 2025 season.
Leave a Reply