The idea of a trade between the New York Yankees and the St. Louis Cardinals for Nolan Arenado might seem like a long shot to many MLB insiders, but former MLB general manager and current MLB Network Radio analyst Jim Bowden believes it’s a perfect fit—especially now. On the February 15 episode of the network’s *Front Office* show, Bowden broke down why the trade makes sense for both teams, particularly in light of the recent drama surrounding Yankees starter Marcus Stroman.
“It’s a complicated trade,” Bowden said, “but it’s the one that makes the most sense for both teams.” For the Yankees, the benefits are twofold. First, they could move on from Stroman, who has expressed dissatisfaction with his expected role, while also shedding part of his $18.5 million salary. Second, the Yankees are in need of a reliable third baseman, and Arenado, a 10-time Gold Glove winner, is one of the best in the game at the hot corner.
However, there are concerns about Arenado’s declining offensive production and his contract. In 152 games last season, Arenado slashed .272/.325/.394 with 16 home runs and 71 RBIs. He has three years and $59 million remaining on the $260 million deal he originally signed with the Colorado Rockies. The contract includes deferred payments and a full no-trade clause, which could complicate any potential deal.
Despite these hurdles, Bowden argues that the trade aligns with the needs of both teams. For the Cardinals, moving Arenado could free up payroll and provide flexibility, while the Yankees would gain a defensive stalwart at third base and address their Stroman situation. While it’s far from a done deal, Bowden’s analysis suggests the trade could be a win-win if the two sides can navigate the complexities.
**Why the Yankees Should Trade Marcus Stroman—and Why the Cardinals Could Bite**
The New York Yankees find themselves at a crossroads with Marcus Stroman, whose dissatisfaction with his expected role has created tension as the 2025 season approaches. Trading Stroman could be a smart move for the Yankees, and the St. Louis Cardinals might just be the perfect trade partner. Here’s why:
### **Why the Yankees Should Trade Stroman**
1. **Clubhouse Chemistry**: Stroman’s unhappiness with his role could disrupt team chemistry, and moving him would eliminate a potential distraction.
2. **Financial Flexibility**: Stroman is owed $18.5 million this season, and trading him would free up payroll for other needs, such as bolstering the lineup or bullpen.
3. **Addressing a Bigger Need**: The Yankees have a glaring hole at third base, and trading Stroman could help them acquire a proven player to fill that void.
### **Why the Cardinals Could Bite**
1. **Pitching Depth**: The Cardinals are always in need of reliable starting pitching, and Stroman, when healthy and motivated, can be a solid mid-rotation arm.
2. **Arenado’s Contract**: St. Louis might be looking to shed some of Nolan Arenado’s remaining $59 million over three years. Trading Arenado for Stroman could help the Cardinals free up payroll while adding a veteran pitcher.
3. **Rebuilding Flexibility**: If the Cardinals are considering a retool, moving Arenado for Stroman and prospects could give them more financial and roster flexibility to build for the future.
### **The Potential Trade Framework**
A deal could center around Stroman and Arenado, with the Yankees absorbing Arenado’s contract to address their third base needs. While Arenado’s offensive numbers have declined (.272/.325/.394 with 16 HRs and 71 RBIs in 2024), his elite defense and leadership could still provide significant value to the Yankees.
### **Conclusion**
Trading Stroman to the Cardinals makes sense for both sides. The Yankees would gain a Gold Glove third baseman while resolving Stroman’s situation, and the Cardinals would add a reliable starter while potentially freeing up payroll. While the deal would be complex—especially with Arenado’s no-trade clause and deferred payments—it’s a move that could benefit both teams as they aim to compete in 2025.
Leave a Reply